I did a similar study back in early 2007, and posted my results on SplitCoastStampers; holy moly, was I ever a rock star then! The biggest names of stamping commented on that post, and the queen herself, Julie Ebersole, mentioned little ole me on her blog. Then I passed out.
But, I knew my work was not finished... there were MORE black inks out there, and clearly I needed them. So, now I've got them. I'm up to 14 black inks, some I've had for years, a few I just opened today (don't tell my husband!).
Here are the players, in alphabetical order by manufacturer:
Georgia Pacific White
PaperTrey Ink Stamper's Select in White
Stampin' Up! Whisper White
Copic Lemon Yellow
Prismacolor Deco Yellow
Stampin' Up! Barely Banana (yes, I know, this is not an alcohol-based marker).
79 degrees F, 44% humidity, a perfect August day in Delaware (just above sea level), and why am I inside again?
- Created a grid and printed it on the three different card stocks with my laser printer.
- Stamped each ink into its appropriate box.
- Carefully cleaned the stamp between inks with a three-step process:
- Ultraclean, then dry
- Stampin' Mist, then dry
- Swipe with a baby wipe
- Allowed grids to dry for 30 minutes while starting this post
- Colored over the lines (on purpose) with the appropriate marker
- Cleaned each marker nib, each time, by coloring on a sheet of printer paper
- Swiped a line of the matching colorless blender pen through each colored area
- Checked for bleeding, feathering & smearing
- Ranked the inks 1, 2, or 3 on each grid
- Entered the results into a spreadsheet, tallied and averaged the results
- A ranking of 1 indicated no black ink movement with the yellow marker or associated clear blender.
- A ranking of 2 indicated no to minimal movement with the yellow, some movement with the clear blender.
- A ranking of 3 was a hot mess. Movement with both marker and blender.
- I threw the SU! marker results out of the averaging, because they were the true definition of hot mess. So, the averaging only took alcohol-based markers into account.
I was VERY impressed with Ranger's Nick Bantock Ink and Tsukineko's Memento... that stuff didn't budge with either of the alcohol-based markers or their clear blenders. Ranger's Adirondack and Distress inks also fared very well. As for the rest of them, well, you can be the judge (click for a larger view):
As for the papers, the PTI smeared the least, followed by the Georgia Pacific, and then the Stampin' Up! Whisper White.
Between the alcohol-based markers themselves, the Prismacolor smeared less than the Copic by 0.05 of a point (averaged), so I'd call that even.
Ranger Nick Bantock or Memento on PaperTrey Ink. Anything else, you'll need to heat set or stay within the lines.
So what do you think?